WP WishList Membership Site Plugin: A Review

Struggling to start and run your own membership site? Made several attempts but for some how you’re not able to start and grow your membership site all because you’re not able to make the technology work for you.

If this is the case my friend..you’re going to love this post.

Over the years I have started and managed many membership sites. Some of them were successful and some of them were colossal failures. Even to this day I struggle with finding the right technologies and platforms that could fit my marketing needs.

Just to give you some idea I have membership sites that run membergate and amember, have a couple of sites that run on wordpress and protected by Amember( Thanks to Ryan Deiss & Dave Moskovitz)

As an information marketer I have advocated the essence of “speed to market”. If you have an idea you need to act on it fast, real fast. Many marketers spend a lot of time thinking and just thinking and in the process they lose out on the market opportunity, myself included sometimes..:)-

Most recently I was introduced to a WordPress plug-in called WP WishList that could convert any wordpress blog into a membership site in minutes.

My initial reaction was, no way I’m going to let a plugin run from the core of my wordpress blog that is not yet proven or has no developer backing.

How many times you have bought a plugin that promises you the earth & heaven and the next thing you heard is, its not supported with your
wordpress version or the theme you are using.

When I I found out that this plugin is developed by Stu McLaren and Stacy Childers, whom I have known for years. I had to give it a shot.

I bought a multi-site license and tested the plugin on several of my sites. Different sites, different membership levels and different purposes altogether.
It was very easy to get started and I even got the 1shoppingcart integration to work.

Last week I attended a live seminar on WishList in Las Vegas during the event I asked several questions on all aspects of the product and get to know the plugin well.

Stu and Tracy assured me that the product is coded to the standards and they are going to ensure that all the future versions will be compliant with wordpress. Apparently they are already working with Corey Miller and Brian Gardner to ensure the plugin will gel well with leading wordpress themes.

(The older version of the plugin used to login the user directly into the membership area upon the purchase, while this worked fine from a usability
perspective, it restricted me to test the conversions using google pixel tracking code. I requested Stu & Tracy for help and in the current version they introduced “after registration” and “after login” pages
)

Here are some enhancements I suggested to Stu & Tracy

Support for WordPress MU. (Imagine running a membership site where users can create their own membership sites and you make a small commission) similar to wordpress.com. Make it compatible with Buddypress. Man you are now dominating the social media.

Ad-serving Platform: Create an ad serving program which triggers banners or text that’s based on membership levels. Stu did talk
mention some upsell enchancements to the plugin that they are planning in the upcoming releases.

Additional content delivery How about delivering selective content(audio, video, e-books, special reports selectively to specific members who are on the same membership level(not at a certain time interval, but by choice at a random). Now Wishlist plugin can do sequential content upgrade and content drip is coming in the next release, but selective content delivery to a specific member is something that is widely supported on amember.

(Stu, can you confirm if Wishlist can do this?)

MoveableTypes Support Extend the plug-in to other blogging platforms such as MoveableTypes. How about MTWishList?

Tight integration with all the plug-ins that amember supports today. Such as open source applications like PHPBB forums etc.

Some of the attendees did raise the point that Stu and Tracy are selling this plug-in for a lot less. To some extent they are but I also think, from an overall product strategy stand point and the WordPress community perspective the $297 multi-site license is a good starting price point.

As I conclude this post here is what I recommend you should do.

If you’re a blogger and if you’re thinking of starting your membership site you should start with WishList plug-in. Wp Wishlist is capable of handling many off the membership site needs. This is a plug-in that has been coded by marketers for marketers and in my opinion you can handle all kinds of front-end and backend offer.

Also when you invest in the Multi-User license make sure you use them on your own sites not your client sites or for someone whom you are building a blog. If you need to build something for your customers, ask Stu for a reseller license.

To see a live functioning site that uses Wp Wishlist visit FastBlogTraffic.com/

To get your own copy of WP Wishlist Plugin visit www.membershipsiteplugin.com

Already using Wp WishList? Your comments please..

Share this post

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on print
Share on email

21 thoughts on “WP WishList Membership Site Plugin: A Review”

  1. Avatar

    Thank you for the article. I did not develop any memebership site, but I work for sure with WordPress and it is good to know about a plugin like this.
    Thanks again.
    Giovanni

  2. Avatar

    Hi Srini,

    Looks like you had have done a very good research on wishlistmember plugin.

    I have been looking for this kind of detailed review on this membership platform and this post is kind of a real good confidence booster for me to make a decision.

    However I wanted to find out if u have any idea about this wishlist membership plugin supporting the affiliate tracking and management responsibilities as well.

    Any idea if it is currently supported in the latest release or there is plan to support it in future?

    Looking forward to hear back from you.

    Thanks,
    -Gaj

  3. Avatar

    Affiliate management is external to the plugin at this time, I suppose.

    Clickbank and 1shopping integration takes care of this. They are still adding more support to 3rd-party gateways at this time. I did not see Paydocom integration, may be its coming.

    Imagine getting all the functionality into a plugin without complicating the ease of use.

  4. Avatar

    Hi Srini,

    I just started a site using WishList Member and my experience has been a good one so far. This is the first membership site I’ve ever put together. Support for the plugin was good (could be more responsive) but overall I’m very happy with the results. I’m really looking forward to the content drip feature. I identified a bug with support and they have given me access to an alpha build. I haven’t had time to try it yet. With any luck it contains content drip! 🙂

    Thanks!

    Pat

  5. Avatar

    Hi Patrick,

    Yes I saw the demo of the content drip at the live event. I think Tracy demonstrated it.

    I am mimicking the content drip feature with multiple membership levels, but its becoming pretty tedious with access levels etc.

    Let me know if you played with it? and what your observations are.

    Thanks
    Srini

  6. Avatar

    If you’re planning on doing anything with wp wishlist that is at all out of the ordinary, I’d beware – they’re kind enough to encrypt the entire thing. Every single file. As a developer, working with wishlist has been an infuriating process.

  7. Avatar

    The alpha build didn’t have content drip unfortunately. 2.18.3 is out now and it doesn’t look like it has content drip either. It’s a bit frustrating that one of the two bugs I reported still isn’t fixed. I was asked to give access to the devs so they could log onto my box and take a look. AFAIK, that was never taken advantage of.

    I realize the above sounds like whining, but overall, I’m very happy with the product. As for the encrypted files, yes, they all are. I’d like there to be a plugin-API in the future so that templates could take advantage of some features. Hopefully that will come.

    Pat

  8. Avatar

    Hi Patrick,

    I am here with Stu Mclaren and Tracy Childers at Ryan Lee’s Continuity Summit in Stamford CT.

    Stu did read this comment. The content drip is coming as an add on and not as the core of the product. It will be released in about 30 days.

    Thanks
    Srini

  9. Avatar

    Have only just discovered the possibilities of using a membership plugin with wordpress, such as Wishlist member, and your post here makes me think that i really need to get on the ball and get a site up and runnning very soon, if not straight away.

    So i guess i will need to buy it first ?

    I was contemplating using Amember, but you have convinced me that this plugin is not only easier to use, but will do just about everything i would ask of a membership script

  10. Avatar

    Thanks for the great review … Do they have the “content drip” available yet? I didn’t see mention of it on their website. Also, have they added affiliate capabilities yet? Do you use Clickbank or 1shopping and why? Thanks! *SmiLes* Suzanne

  11. Avatar

    The content drip still isn’t there (I just bought the plugin). It would really be nice if WLM worked WITH aweber (esp. from the content drip perspective). Essentially, the drip function should mimic an autoresponder sequence, but it would be way cool if you could “prompt” a subscriber when his new content had been delivered.

    I’m kind of peeved at the slowness with which WLM is being developed.

  12. Avatar

    Yes Bill, the content drip function may not be coming after all. We have to find our own ways of dealing with it. That means more opportunities for WP plugin developers around this area.

    This is the area where Amember will continue to thrive

  13. Avatar

    Everyone should think twice about using WLM if you are planning to use any other plug-ins. I am having a devil of a time getting WishList to run with SimplePressForum (which I would think is a fairly standard use for a membership site) and have been talking with WL for several days through their Support network. After being asked to supply FTP access, I received the following response:

    Hi Craig,

    Thanks for the information.

    Unfortunately if a plugin conflict is creating the issue, there is not much we can do in terms of helping you.

    However, I will pass this on to the developers to verify that this is the case.

    Take care,

    Greg France

    1. Avatar

      Hi Craig,

      This is a classical open source problem. My take on this is, no matter which way you go there will always be issues with plugins and themes.

      Not all plugins and themes will work with one another. A reality we have to accept and move on.

      Given all the advancements, For most people, The days of loading all kinds of plugins into the blog and expecting that everything else will work in harmomy are coming to an end.

      I know Stu and Tracy are reaching out to mainstream theme & plugin creators for their blessings, which is a good thing.

      Srini

  14. Avatar

    Srini,

    I am the founder/developer of a membership script for WordPress, at DigitalAccessPass.com (DAP).

    I just wanted to throw DAP into the ring here, as we are one of the best available alternatives to wishlist.

    For a detailed comparison of DAP vs WishList, please check out http://DigitalAccessPass.com/showdown.php

    Appreciate the opportunity to comment here.

    Thanks,

    – Ravi Jayagopal
    Founder & Developer, DigitalAccessPass

  15. Avatar

    Hi. I running WPMU so I purchased Amember. I find it really technical and hard to set up. (Anyone want to buy it cheap??)

    So I’m considering purchasing another membership plugin, even though there may not be any others out there that work well with WPMU.

    So far I think the top candidates are:
    >>WishList Member
    >>WP-eMember (which costs considerably less than WishList and integrates well with WP Affiliate Software)
    >>S2Member (which is free, and amazing but doesn’t support shopping carts yet)

    ~Jeff
    MileHighTechGuy

  16. Avatar

    I’m looking for a WP plugin that will let me display a geographically searchable directory of members (e.g. Yoga teachers around the world). Will wishlist do this?

  17. Avatar

    I tried WishList Member about six weeks ago and had all kinds of registration problems. Other users were having similar problems so I was not alone. Although I thought the basic structure of the plugin was excellent, I simply could not solve the registration issue while running WordPress 3.0.

    Perhaps the problem has been solved, but I waited almost two weeks without an adequate solution.

    Lowell

  18. Avatar

    Lowell,

    Then I highly recommend that you give DigitalAccessPass.com (DAP) a try. DAP works great with WP 3.0.

    I am the founder & co-developer of DAP, and our team will help you get your membership site up and running quickly.

    Also check out our testimonials page on our site (and also google us) to see the rave reviews we are getting about our software and support.

    Thanks for your time.

    – Ravi Jayagopal
    Founder & Co-Developer, DAP

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.